(06 OCT 1873-07 AUG 1951)
Rachel (Tup) Judge 
(08 MAY 1909-19 JAN 1929)
| +---David Benge (06 FEB 1813-12 AUG 1876)
| +---David James Benge (22 OCT 1844-15 SEP 1921)
| | +---Philadelphia (Sarah) Roberts (18 JAN 1816-15 APR 1879)
+---Jane Benge (03 APR 1880-02 MAY 1961)
| +---John Francis (-12 AUG 1872)
+---Julia Francis (08 MAY 1848-13 JUL 1907)
+---Frances Ottley (-JUL 1901)